GSM Vs CDMA Vs LTE

GSM Vs CDMA Vs LTE – Your Detailed Technology Comparison

A lot of people have been asking me lately about the differences between GSM vs CDMA vs LTE.

Here’s a quick primer on each of these technologies and how they compare to each other.

GSM (Global System for Mobile Communications) is the most widely used mobile technology in the world.

It’s used by most carriers in North America, Europe, Asia and Africa.

CDMA (Code Division Multiple Access) is a competitor to GSM that uses a different modulation scheme and other techniques to achieve higher data rates.

It’s used by Sprint in the US, as well as many carriers in China and Japan.

LTE (Long Term Evolution) is an updated version of 3G that offers faster speeds and greater capacity than previous technologies.

It is simply what is known as 4G.

It’s currently being deployed around the world by carriers like AT&T, T-Mobile USA and Verizon Wireless.

With this summary, let’s now dig deeper into each of these technologies and make you understand what each of them is and how it works.

Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM) overview

GSM is an advanced cellular network standard used by most carriers in North America, Europe and Africa.

It is a highly scalable and flexible technology that has served mobile operators well over the years.

It’s a multi-band technology that uses both TDMA and FDMA (frequency division multiple access).

Both the carrier and user’s parts of the network need to support GSM.

There are two main components of a GSM carrier:

  1. The Mobile Station (MS): It’s the device that you carry in your pocket that has its own unique identification number assigned to it by the network operator. It is used to communicate with the network as well as to receive and send data.
  2. The Base Station Subsystem (BSS): It actually controls the radio resources and sends the voice or data to and from the mobile station. This can be controlled by a BSC (Base Station Controller) used for small networks or an MSC (Mobile Switching Center) used for large networks.

GSM is based on TDMA (Time Division Multiple Access).

This means that data is transmitted in bursts that take turns sharing a frequency channel.

A channel basically consists of time and frequency.

TDMA assigns time slots (or slots) for each user to send data at the same time.

These could be either centrally controlled or released on-demand by users.

During a call, a different set of users are assigned bandwidth and don’t run into each other as they are using different channels.

The GSM system has 2 types of channels:

  • Frequency Bands – Each carrier uses one or more frequency bands to transmit data at various rates and bit rates depending on the needs of the operator. Not all bands are used or supported in every country. There are three frequency bands supported in most GSM networks:
  • 900 MHz (low band), which is used by many carriers and tends to travel farther and penetrate walls less effectively than other bands. 1,800 MHz (medium band), which is the most common band worldwide. 2,100 MHz (high band), also popular in North America, it does not have as good coverage as the medium band.
  • TDMA (Time Division Multiple Access) channels – this refers to the time slots assigned to each user. Sometimes the term ‘time slot’ is used but it’s a bit of a misnomer because in TDMA it’s not really about how much time is allocated for a call or data transmission but how many timeslots in which different calls can occur.

CDMA (Code Division Multiple Access) Overview

CDMA is a type of digital transmission technology that is based on spread spectrum.

It’s a rival to TDMA, and like GSM it’s a highly scalable technology that has served operators well over the years.

It uses both TDMA and FDMA (frequency division multiple access) with each carrier/user part of the network having to support CDMA as well, in the same way, that GSM does.

In simple terms, the CDMA refers to all the protocols used in 2nd Generation (2G) and 3rd Generation (3G) data transmissions.

It’s a multi-band technology that uses two main bands:

  1.  800 MHz (800 MHz bands).
  2. 1,900 MHz (1.9 GHz band).

Different regions have different frequency allocations for each of these bands.

How CDMA and TDMA compare:

CMDA is based on FDMA and uses the same modulation scheme as FSK (frequency shift keying).

This means that, like GSM, it can be thought of as a progression from TDMA.

Unlike GSM, the number of timeslots allocated to each user is different in CDMA.

With CMDA there is a downlink (from the base station to the handset) and uplink (from handset to base station).

TDMA uses a combination of FSK and PSK (pseudo-noise codes).

This is what makes it an easy transition for CDMA.

There is an average capacity of the system with the TDMA while there’s a large capacity of the system with CDMA.

TDMA and CDMA are pretty similar but there are a few differences.

Mobile/ Handphone: The following list illustrates the key differences between TDMA and CDMA mobile phone systems:

  1. The frequency bands for mobile phones are much smaller than those used for cellular networks. In most cases, TDMA is used alongside CMDA (e.g., GSM) to provide a second band for use in mobiles.
  2. The traffic in a mobile network is much higher, which has implications for design and equipment.
  3. The spectrum used in TDMA is divided into smaller channels than is the case in CDMA. This means that channels can be reused in the former case (with some bandwidth loss), whereas the latter doesn’t allow this due to its spread-spectrum nature.
  4. The traffic in mobile towers is much higher, which has implications for tower design and equipment.
  5. In TDMA systems, the signaling between the base station and the handset is digitized, while in CDMA systems it is analog. This means that the expansion of TDMA networks to mobile phones has not seen as much development as CDMA networks have.

LTE overview

LTE is a 4G technology that has revolutionized the wireless industry.

It’s one of the most recent technologies to be introduced to the mobile world, and it’s also one of the most advanced.

It was developed by an organization called 3GPP and it’s basically what is known as 4G.

Although LTE is commonly used for many different wireless technologies, its main emphasis is on mobile broadband Internet access.

LTE is a high-speed data transmission technology and the most advanced, high-capacity wireless network standard that has ever been introduced in the mobile industry.

It was designed to provide better voice and data coverage and a faster data speed compared to past technologies.

When implemented, LTE will have much better performance than any of the previous generations of GSM/GPRS/EDGE/3G cellular networks.

The difference between LTE and GSM and CDMA

LTE (Long Term Evolution) and GSM are different in both the core network as well as the radio interface.

As mentioned earlier on, GSM is an older technology that is more mature but has more legacy architecture in its network and systems design.

LTE on the other hand is a newer technology that is less mature with fewer deployments but has a very modern architecture and design from ground up.

It’s important to note that GSM (mostly CDMA) is run on small cells as well so the difference between CDMA and GSM is not very significant in most cases.

In short, this could be simplified as follows:

  • GSM and LTE use OFDMA (orthogonal frequency division multiple access) while CDMA can have FDM (frequency division multiplexing). OFDMA is a more efficient scheme of spectrum use which makes it possible to send more bits per unit time.
  • CDMA uses spread spectrum in its digital transmissions, while GSM and LTE do not.
  • TDMA is a scheme of time-division multiplexing which is used in both GSM and LTE systems.
  • FDM stands for frequency division multiplexing, this means that radio channels are divided into smaller chunks of different frequencies to send data from multiple users/handsets in one network at the same time.

FAQs

Is GSM or TDMA better?

GSM and TDMA are both really good transmission techniques, but the consensus has it that GSM is better than TDMA in almost all aspects, especially the speed of data transmission and voice call quality.

What is CDMA?

CDMA stands for Code Division Multiple Access, a type of multiplexing scheme used in 2G and 3G networks to transmit multiple users over one radio channel.

It’s considered an evolutionary step forward from TDMA systems like GSM.

What is the difference between GSM and CDMA?

The main difference between GSM and CDMA is the underlying technology used to transmit data and voice.

GSM is based on FDMA (frequency division multiple access) while CDMA is based on FDMA/TDMA (a single channel divided into multiple timeslots).

What is LTE?

Meaning of LTE stands for Long Term Evolution, a major step forward from 3G technologies like UMTS.

Both GSM and LTE use OFDMA (orthogonal frequency division multiple access).

Is dual-mode possible with TDMA?

Yes, it’s really possible thanks to the innovation of TDMA/CDMA.

However, in some cases it’s not used because it is either too much work to make the mobile computer hardware work as both a TDMA and CDMA modem, or could be cost-prohibitive.

In many regions, most of the operators run CDMA only.

Conclusion

TDMA is not as popular as GSM and LTE, but both TDMA and CDMA are very common in the telecom industry.

Both of them are strong technologies and serve the operators well.

In fact, they have been so good that they’ve convinced governments to allocate more spectrum instead of using less or no spectrum at all.

ThemeScene Team

We are revenge of the nerds in tech, with Guss, Jenny, Vanessa, Ursula, and John at the helm, here to help you with your questions related to streaming, internet, Wi-Fi connection and bringing some sense to this complicated tech world.

Need help? then don't hesitate to contact us

Search