We compared internet services from Frontier vs Mediacom to see who is the better ISP. Sometimes people find themselves torn between two internet service providers. Well, it’s understandable if something like this has happened to you.
The pricing, internet packages, upfront fees, and customer reviews from both service providers might seem enticing. However, there are always a few things that set them apart and make one a better choice over the other. We will go through all the details regarding Frontier and Mediacom to give you a clearer picture of where these internet service providers stand and help you make an informed decision.
Table of Contents
Frontier overview
Frontier is a familiar internet service company to many people. It’s a company that is known to have made the crucial step of reaching the often forgotten areas. This is something that the other internet service providers have overlooked and ignored for a very long time.
In a nutshell, FrontierFrontier provides DSL, cable, and fiber internet to the different states in the United States. Aside from that, the company also offers offer phone and TV services to residential homes and businesses that seek these services and the internet. Over the years, FrontierFrontier has been expanding its boundaries in a bid to reach more states, and much of its focus is on the rural customers.
Mediacom overview
For quite a while, Mediacom has been among the nation’s largest cable internet service providers. However, this didn’t make them lag behind when all the other providers began to upgrade their offerings. At the moment, Mediacom also provides high-speed internet to residential subscribers and businesses. Depending on where exactly you stay, Mediacom may not be new to you. It serves much of the Midwest and Deep South parts of the nation. Once again, these are areas that are mostly overlooked by many of the ISPs. It’s actually commendable that people in the remote regions and Suburbs are allowed the rare opportunity to enjoy high bandwidth gigabit speeds.
Coverage and Availability
Currently, Mediacom is offering its services to about 7.5 million people in Lowa, Georgia, Illinois, and nineteen other states. Its services can be found in top cities such as Albany, Springfield, Des Moines, and Columbus. With that said, much of its coverage is in the urban areas and the suburbs. This means that the people who happen to live farther away from the urban areas might not access the Mediacom services. You can check the company’s coverage map on its website to determine whether the service is available in your locality.
Frontier, on the other hand, has coverage in 26 states across the US. Its greatest coverage is in the states of California, Florida, Texas, and Connecticut. In addition, the company is estimated to serve 30.5 million people earning it a spot on the list of the top DSL internet providers in the US by coverage area. The frontier fiber service is accessible to approximately 9.5 million people making this ISP the fifth-largest fiber broadband.
On that note, we can deduce FrontierFrontier has a larger coverage area compared to Mediacom. Furthermore, if you are interested in the fiber optic internet service, there is a higher chance of accessing it with FrontierFrontier than its counterpart.
High-Speed Internet Technology
Nowadays, technology is everything, and we can barely imagine how our lives would be without it. Frontier provides broadband internet and phone services to its customer through mainly DSL and fiber technology. The DSL internet service is provided over the already existing phone lines. In this case, the company provides internet access over the same wires used for the landline service. DSL internet is affordable and more accessible, but it is way slower than cable.
Frontier also offers fiber-optic service. The FiOS connections basically send a high bandwidth connection over the last mile to residential and business subscribers. Fiber technology is usually the most robust broadband option for customers. Cable internet is typically faster than DSL.
When it comes to Mediacom, the internet, phone, and TV services are provided using a coaxial cables network, which uses the leverage TV lines installed on utility poles. These cover the last mile to the local residential and business customers.
Internet prices and plans
Frontier doesn’t have many internet plan options, as you would find with some other internet service providers such as Mediacom. It consists of three solid DSL plans and six fiber plans. The heartening thing is that majority of the locations have at least three plan options to choose from. With that said, if you live in any of the places where the frontier FiOS service is available, then you are in luck. The frontier FiOS fiber internet is highly recommended mostly because it’s more reliable and fast.
Another thing is that the fiber internet comes at incredibly low prices. The Simply FiOS Gig plan costs about $75 per month. That’s not a high price when you consider the speeds you will be getting. Also, if you live in an area where the Frontier FiOS internet is not available, there are DSL options to pick from, and these are offered at reasonably low prices. For instance, the best internet plan would be the one that comes with 45 Mbps speeds, and it costs almost $50 a month.
Moving on to Mediacom, there are lots of options for the customers, which is always a good thing since internet usage is not the same for all. For instance, they offer 60 Mbps, 100, 200, 500, and 1,000 Mbps plans. These are more than enough plan options to suit the needs of various internet users. The prices appear to be enticing at first, but things are bound to change after the first 12 months. Mediacom will up your monthly bill by $30 each year until you reach and start paying the standard case.
It’s a little disappointing that Mediacom chooses to follow the pack and do what the other ISPs are doing. Nobody likes to deal with price hikes because something that appeared to be a sweet deal gradually evolves and turns into a super high price. Therefore, if affordability was the main reason you chose Mediacom over Frontier, you may not be able to afford your internet package in the next coming years.
What Are The Internet Speeds?
The truth is many users like to look at the internet speeds when picking out the internet plans. This is because different internet speeds are suitable for a variety of tasks and the number of users. For that reason, internet providers must give their customers a variety of speed options to suit different needs. Frontier doesn’t fall short, and for the most part, people are given a reasonable array of speed options.
The FiOS internet service consists of 50mbps 500 Mbps and 1,000 Mbps download speeds. This pretty much covers any household type, including those who like streaming, gaming, or working from home. Keep in mind, this is a fiber connection, and hence the download and upload speeds are reliably fast. As a matter of fact, FrontierFrontier goes the extra mile to provide its customers with symmetrical upload and download speeds on the FiOS service. This means that if you regularly upload large files online, you will no longer have to endure headaches and the stress that comes with extremely slow upload speeds.
While the frontier FiOS service is the best you can ever find, I wouldn’t say the same about the DSL service. The DSL plans download speed options are not that bad, especially because its fastest plan has 45 Mbps speeds. The only problem is that DSL is usually less reliable in terms of speed performance. If you have multiple devices that use the internet at the same time, we wouldn’t recommend going for anything less than 25 Mbps.
Mediacom provides plenty of speed options for just about any kind of internet users. If the frontier FiOS service is not accessible in your area, then the Mediacom cable internet would be your best available option. It’s more robust and reliable than DSL. The downside is cable internet tends to experience slow speeds and downtimes during the peak hours.
How Good is It For Streaming, Web Browsing and Gaming
We want to compare how these two service providers cope with streaming, gaming, and web browsing. These are basically the everyday internet tasks among the users, and there might be people who want to know how Frontier and Mediacom compare.
The avid streamers and gamers would be better off with the Frontier FiOS service. All of the FiOS plans are suitable for a great streaming experience. The 500 Mbps plan will work perfectly fine for a medium-sized family with more than two regular streamers and gamers. You don’t have to worry about lagging during gameplay or drop in connections when streaming your favorite show on Netflix with such speeds.
If you only want the internet to check emails and web browsing, then the frontier DSL service will cut it. However, the DSL service may not be what you are looking for when it comes to streaming and gaming. The 45 Mbps plan can do a decent job at streaming but doesn’t offer the much-needed speed performance reliability for an excellent gaming experience.
On the other hand, Mediacom does reasonably well in gaming and streaming, depending on the internet plan that you pick. The best gaming experience is achieved with the 1000 Mbps plan. This will ensure there is no lagging and interruptions while you are gaming. Any of the other Mediacom internet plans can deliver a decent streaming experience, but it depends on the number of internet users in the household. If there are more than two internet users who also stream from time to time, internet 500 and internet 1 Gig plans are more suitable.
Mediacom provides more than enough internet speeds for web browsing and other activities such as checking emails and shopping online.
How fast are they?
You might want to know how Frontier and Mediacom internet speeds stack up. How fast are these two internet providers, and which one is better in terms of speeds? Well, that’s what we are about to find out.
The one thing that people look for in the internet service providers is consistency and reliability. However, FrontierFrontier falls a bit short in this. An FCC study report showed that the Frontier FiOS provided only 72% of the advertised speeds. While this is not the worst figure, it’s not the best either. Other providers score higher than this. The DSL service did far worse, delivering only 33% of the advertised speeds.
In terms of latency, FrontierFrontier performed really well. The latency measuring was at 19.5 milliseconds, which is way lower than the average. The average packet loss was actually less than 0.4%, which is also quite good. Therefore, the frontier FiOS internet is less likely to disappoint gamers, streamers, and those who participate in video conferences. On that note, we can say that the frontier FiOS internet speeds are incredible, but the DSL speeds might be lackluster.
Similar to FrontierFrontier, Mediacom has internet speeds that go all the way to 1 Gbps. That said, the question is whether these speeds are consistent. An FCC report showed that Mediacom provided 61% of the advertised speeds. This means that there are times customers don’t get the speeds they paid for. This is also lower than the score of the frontier fiber internet. Such statistics don’t earn Mediacom a place among the fastest ISPs but instead puts it right in the middle of the pack.
Frontier vs. Mediacom Data caps
Without any doubt, we all know the internet has become a necessity and an essential utility. Therefore, a data cap on your internet may not be too convenient for some people. Unfortunately, the Mediacom internet has data caps. Thus you have to keep an eye on the amount of data you’re using. In case you exceed the data cap with Mediacom, you will have to pay $10 for every extra 50 GB increment. Well, it might be comforting to know that the data restrictions are set high with the 1 Gig plan having a 6 TB data cap.
If all you want is the internet with no restrictions, FrontierFrontier is your best option. There are no data caps put on its internet plans. What I mean is absolutely zero data caps, even for the DSL plans. You can browse the web, stream, game, and never have to worry about surpassing data limits. The best part of it is that FrontierFrontier doesn’t even think of throttling your speeds. This is a blessing, especially during these times when people are working, studying, and doing most of their activities at home.
Contracts, equipment, and fees
Contracts
Internet service providers are well known for their hidden fees. Well, Mediacom doesn’t appear to have failed to jump on that bandwagon. You have to sign a contract to receive the Mediacom services, but fortunately, these are month to month. The problem is that the contracts are also loaded with a lot of price changes. The price of your internet plan might change and get too expensive for you to afford it in the next two years. But since the company offers monthly contracts for all its plans, you can choose to cancel the service anytime if the price goes ludicrously high.
If you wish to grab the FrontierFrontier FiOS plans, you will need to sign a contract. That’s not good news for the contract averse users. However, the DSL plans are contract-free, so at least there is still something to lean on. You can cancel without worrying about the ever hefty early termination fees. That said, we would like FrontierFrontier to join its counterparts and offer contract-free plans for the FiOS service too.
Equipment
Once you have everything you need, including an internet plan, the only thing remaining would be a modem. You can rent that from Mediacom at the cost of $11.50 per month or purchase your own. On the other hand, frontier subscribers are issued with a FiOS Gateway Router at the cost of $10 a month. Well, this is a lower price compared to what the Mediacom users are paying (hey, we’ll save every coin).
The catch is that FrontierFrontier still continues to charge you for the equipment rental fee regardless of whether you decide to use their Gateway Router or not. Hence, buying your own equipment will not help in this case. You might as well use their equipment since you will be paying for it anyway. If you prefer purchasing your own internet equipment, you’re better off with Mediacom.
Service fees
The Mediacom service fees book contains only a few pages. The installation fee is charged at $99 but can be waived if you opt to sign up online. Subscribers are also required to pay $10 as a one-time activation fee. Some of us don’t understand why we have to pay for this, but that’s how it is.
Frontier, on the other hand, has a couple of service fees, some of which we find a little weird. For starters, the installation fee is charged at $75, while the activation fee is a whopping $85. If you thought the Mediacom service fees are high, think again, and we are just getting started. There is more such as the equipment delivery fee at $9.99 and the broadband processing fee at $10.
Frontier vs. Mediacom: Customer service
You wouldn’t find an Internet Service Provider that has an excellent score in customer service. These are companies that deal with thousands to millions of people, and while you can’t win with everyone, you at least have to try. It’s fair to say that both FrontierFrontier and Mediacom don’t do exceptionally well in the customer service category if the past scores from ACSI are anything to go by.
For instance, a 2019 ACSI (American Customer Satisfaction Index) report gave FrontierFrontier a score of 55/100. This is actually one of the lowest scores in the category. Mediacom follows suit and is at the bottom of the class in terms of customer service and customer satisfaction. Mediacom and FrontierFrontier can surely do better than this.
Pros and cons
Mediacom pros
- Short monthly contracts
- High speeds
- A wide array of plan options
Mediacom cons
- Small data caps for some of the plans
- Price hikes after the first year
Frontier pros
- Reasonable prices for the fiber internet plans
- Unlimited data for the internet plans
- DSL options suitable for the rural areas
Frontier cons
- The fiber plans consist of a contract
- DSL plans have a maximum speed of 45 Mbps
- Random and weird service fees
Bundle packages
Frontier offers affordable bundle packages, and its TV service is excellent. Besides, you get to top it off with incredibly fast fiber internet service. There are also a couple of bundles with DISH if that’s your preference. Mediacom is not left behind and brings to the table fast internet speeds and fairly good TV offerings.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Mediacom charge for installation?
The Mediacom installation fee is $99, but you might end up paying less if you sign up online.
Is frontier cable going out of business?
Frontier communications did file for bankruptcy in April 2020, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going out of business. There won’t be any interruptions of service for the frontier customers.
Is FrontierFrontier better than Mediacom?
If you need an ISP with many speed options, Mediacom is the most suitable option. However, if you are into high-speed fiber internet, then you might as well go for Frontier FiOS service.
Conclusion
When looking for the best internet service provider, there are undoubtedly many things that you look at to ensure you arrive at the wisest decision. Frontier has its juicy offerings such as reliable and super-fast fiber internet. The customers also get to enjoy unlimited data even with the DSL internet. But Mediacom provides a selection of internet plans, which is invaluable to the people who need moderate speeds.
